Bar soap decision file

Dr. Squatch Alternatives from Independent Soap Brands

By the Trusted Labels team · Published October 30, 2026

Unilever has owned Dr. Squatch since September 2, 2025. If you bought it because it was an independent brand, these bar soaps and a deodorant come from makers with no corporate parent on record. Choose by scent and skin.

A stack of four handmade bar soaps on a gray counter

Start here

Four Dr. Squatch alternatives, by what you liked

Scores come from our brand reviews. As an Amazon Associate, Trusted Labels earns from qualifying purchases. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided “as is” and is subject to change or removal at any time.

  1. Bend Soap Company Mount Bachelor Pine Goat Milk Soap (4-Pack)

    Woodsy bar soap, 4-pack: the maker says it smells like pines and firs. Made with goat milk. For Dr. Squatch fans who liked the outdoorsy scents.

    9/10 Ingredients Independent

    Bend Soap Company Mount Bachelor Pine Goat Milk Soap (4-Pack)

  2. Dr. Bronner's Pure-Castile Bar Soap Variety 8-Pack (5 oz bars)

    Variety pack, 8 bars: one each of Peppermint, Eucalyptus, Tea Tree, Citrus, Lavender, Rose, Almond and Unscented. For someone who liked trying Dr. Squatch scents.

    10/10 Ingredients Independent

    Dr. Bronner's Pure-Castile Bar Soap Variety 8-Pack (5 oz bars)

  3. Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve Oatmeal, Honey & Goat Milk Soap Bar

    Unscented bar, 5.6 oz: no added fragrance or essential oils. For someone whose skin or nose did not like a strongly scented bar.

    9/10 Ingredients Independent

    Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve Oatmeal, Honey & Goat Milk Soap Bar

  4. Humble Brands Sensitive Skin Baking Soda-Free Deodorant (Palo Santo & Frankincense, 2.5 oz)

    Deodorant stick, 2.5 oz: no aluminum and no baking soda. Four base ingredients plus essential oils for a woodsy scent. For someone switching from Dr. Squatch deodorant.

    9/10 Ingredients Independent

    Humble Brands Sensitive Skin Baking Soda-Free Deodorant (Palo Santo & Frankincense, 2.5 oz)

For a woodsy bar soap

Bend Soap Company

Mount Bachelor Pine goat milk soap, 4 bars, 4.5 oz each

Start here if the woodsy scent was why you bought Dr. Squatch. Bend Soap is a family company that makes goat milk soap, and this bar is its pine scent.

The maker says it smells like pines and firs. A 4-bar pack also makes an easy gift.

Check before choosing

The scent is not only essential oils. The maker also lists a natural pine and vanilla scent blend.

Want no scent? Bend sells an Unscented 4-pack on the same Amazon page.

For trying new scents, or a gift

Dr. Bronner's

Pure-Castile bar soap, 8 scents, 5 oz each

Pick this if you liked working through Dr. Squatch scents. One pack holds eight different bars, from peppermint to unscented.

Dr. Bronner's makes castile soap from plant oils. The same bars come in single scents once you find a favorite.

Check before choosing

You get one bar of each scent, so this pack will not stock up a favorite.

Rose and Almond are floral and sweet. Skip it if you only want woodsy scents.

For skin that reacts to scent

Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve

Oatmeal, honey and goat milk bar, unscented, 5.6 oz

Pick this if strongly scented soap bothers your skin or nose. The maker adds no fragrance or essential oils to this bar.

Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve makes it with oatmeal, honey and goat milk.

Check before choosing

It is one bar, not a pack.

It still smells faintly of oats and honey from its ingredients.

For a Dr. Squatch deodorant swap

Humble Brands

Sensitive Skin Baking Soda-Free Deodorant, Palo Santo & Frankincense, 2.5 oz

Dr. Squatch sells deodorant too. If you used it, this stick is a close swap from a brand with no corporate parent on record.

The maker's Sensitive Skin formula has four base ingredients: MCT oil, corn starch, magnesium hydroxide and candelilla wax, plus essential oils for scent.

Check before choosing

Choose Sensitive Skin on the label. Humble’s Original sticks use some of the same scent names but have baking soda and beeswax.

Want no scent? Humble sells the same formula unscented on its own site.

Buying a gift

Gift packs for a Dr. Squatch fan

Dr. Squatch sets are a common gift. These multipacks come from the same independent brands. For more ideas by person, see our non-toxic gift guide.

Dr. Bronner's

Castile soap gift pack, 3.4 oz bottles

Ingredients 10/10 Independent

Travel-size bottles of liquid castile soap in several scents. Each one works as body wash and hand soap.

Skip if they only use bar soap.

Bend Soap Company

Unscented goat milk soap, 4 bars

Ingredients 9/10 Independent

Four 4.5 oz bars with no added fragrance or essential oils, made with goat milk, coconut, olive and red palm oils.

Skip if they are vegan, or want a scented bar.

Humble Brands

Palo Santo & Frankincense deodorant, 3 sticks

Ingredients 9/10 Independent

Three 2.5 oz sticks of Humble’s best-known scent. Each stick lasts about three months, the maker says.

Skip if baking soda bothers their skin. This Original formula has it; give the Sensitive Skin stick above instead.

Follow the evidence

Who owns Dr. Squatch now

Unilever announced the deal on June 23, 2025 and completed it on September 2, 2025, buying 98.7% of the shares under an agreement with growth equity firm Summit Partners. Its 2025 financial statements put the price at €1,243 million. Our Dr. Squatch ownership file links every source.

A sale does not prove a formula changed. No source we cite shows a Dr. Squatch formula change after the deal, so if you like your bar and ownership does not matter to you, keep it.

Separately, Dr. Squatch has agreed to a proposed class action settlement over products sold as natural. It denies the claims. The ownership file explains the settlement and its dates.

The brands above are ones we list as independent: Bend Soap Company, Dr. Bronner's, Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve and Humble Brands. Each review explains how we classify its ownership.

Questions

Questions before switching

Is Dr. Squatch still independent?

No. Unilever bought 98.7% of Dr. Squatch on September 2, 2025. Its 2025 financial statements put the price at €1,243 million. Our ownership file has the sources.

What is a good Dr. Squatch soap alternative?

It depends on why you bought Dr. Squatch. For a woodsy smell, start with the Bend Soap pine bars. To try many scents, the Dr. Bronner’s 8-bar pack. For sensitive skin, the unscented Chagrin Valley oatmeal bar. All three brands have no corporate parent on record.

Is there a Dr. Squatch deodorant alternative?

Yes. The Humble Sensitive Skin stick above has no aluminum and no baking soda, with a woodsy palo santo and frankincense scent from essential oils. For more choices, compare our four Native deodorant alternatives.

Which of these is cheaper than Dr. Squatch?

We don’t list prices because they change every day on Amazon. Check the price per bar or per ounce on each listing. Multipacks like the Bend 4-pack and the Dr. Bronner’s 8-pack let you compare per bar.

Did you test these soaps?

No. We do not test products in person. These picks come from each maker’s ingredient list and our ownership records, and each brand review shows its sources.

Are goat milk soaps vegan?

No. The Bend Soap and Chagrin Valley bars are made with goat milk, and the Chagrin Valley bar also has honey. The Dr. Bronner’s bars are made from plant oils.