Badger
Unscented Hand Balm, olive oil and beeswax, 2 oz tin
Ingredients 10/10 Independent
Two ingredients, olive oil and beeswax, from a family-owned B Corp in New Hampshire.
Ingredient check
Vaseline Jelly lists one ingredient, white petrolatum, which FDA rules allow as a skin protectant at 30 to 100 percent. The worry you may have heard comes from an EU rule about petrolatum whose refining history is not known.

The short answer
Vaseline’s own product page lists a single ingredient: white petrolatum USP, better known as petroleum jelly. FDA rules for over-the-counter skin protectants list petrolatum and white petrolatum as active ingredients at 30 to 100 percent.
The concern people repeat comes from Europe. EU cosmetics law lists petrolatum among prohibited substances unless its full refining history is known and the substance it is made from can be shown not to be a carcinogen. Petrolatum that meets that condition is allowed, so the rule turns on refining.
Aquaphor is a different product: 41% petrolatum plus mineral oil, wax and lanolin alcohol, a known allergen for some people. If you would rather skip petroleum, the three balms below are made with plant oils and beeswax.
We read the published label and the sources below. We did not test the product, and this is not medical advice: a doctor or dermatologist can tell you what suits your skin.
What's on the label
White Petrolatum Usp (100%)Petroleum jelly
Skin protectant and emollient that seals in moisture. FDA's over-the-counter skin protectant rules list petrolatum and white petrolatum as active ingredients at 30 to 100 percent.
Known concern EU cosmetics law lists petrolatum among substances prohibited in cosmetic products, except if the full refining history is known and it can be shown that the substance from which it is produced is not a carcinogen. Petrolatum that meets that condition falls outside the prohibition.
Petrolatum 41%Active ingredient: Petroleum jelly
Skin protectant and emollient that seals in moisture. FDA's over-the-counter skin protectant rules list petrolatum and white petrolatum as active ingredients at 30 to 100 percent.
Known concern EU cosmetics law lists petrolatum among substances prohibited in cosmetic products, except if the full refining history is known and it can be shown that the substance from which it is produced is not a carcinogen. Petrolatum that meets that condition falls outside the prohibition.
Mineral OilMineral oil
Moisturizes and softens skin. FDA’s over-the-counter skin protectant rules list mineral oil as an active ingredient at 50 to 100 percent.
Ceresin
Lanolin AlcoholWool alcohols, from lanolin
Moisturizes and softens skin.
Known concern Lanolin, including lanolin alcohol, can cause allergic skin reactions in some people; the American Contact Dermatitis Society named lanolin its 2023 Allergen of the Year. Allergy is thought to be rare on healthy skin. People with long-term inflammatory skin conditions, broken skin or wounds are at higher risk.
Panthenol
GlycerinGlycerin, a moisture-holding ingredient (humectant)
Holds in moisture and adds smoothness. FDA’s skin protectant rules list glycerin as an active ingredient at 20 to 45 percent.
BisabololBisabolol, a soothing compound found in chamomile
A component of chamomile essential oil. Cosmetic bisabolol can come from plants or be made synthetically.
Vaseline’s list comes from vaseline.com; Aquaphor’s from Beiersdorf’s drug label on DailyMed, the US government’s drug-label site. Lanolin is the biggest difference: if you react to it, Vaseline Jelly and the swaps below leave it out.
Ownership
Unilever has owned Vaseline since 1986.
Aquaphor belongs to Beiersdorf AG, based in Hamburg, Germany.
If you want to switch
Each is made with plant oils and beeswax instead of petrolatum, from a family- or founder-owned brand. Balms feel different from jelly: they melt on contact with skin rather than staying slick.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Unscented Hand Balm, olive oil and beeswax, 2 oz tin
Ingredients 10/10 Independent
Two ingredients, olive oil and beeswax, from a family-owned B Corp in New Hampshire.
Organic Magic Balm, Baby Unscented
Ingredients 10/10 Independent
Beeswax with avocado, jojoba, coconut, olive and hemp oils, from a family-owned company. No added scent.
Organic Nipple Butter, lanolin-free, 2 fl oz
Ingredients 9/10 Independent
A lanolin-free balm from a founder-owned brand, made for nursing parents.
Skip if you want an all-purpose balm: it is sold for breastfeeding.
Keep reading: Skincare brand directory · Baby care brand directory · Who owns your personal care brands
Questions
No. Vaseline Jelly lists one ingredient, white petrolatum. Aquaphor Healing Ointment is 41% petrolatum plus mineral oil, ceresin, lanolin alcohol, panthenol, glycerin and bisabolol. The lanolin alcohol is the main difference if you have sensitive skin.
No. EU cosmetics law prohibits petrolatum unless its full refining history is known and the substance it is made from can be shown not to be a carcinogen. Petrolatum that meets that condition can be used.
That is the question the EU rule addresses: before petrolatum can go into cosmetics there, its refining history must be known and its starting material shown not to be a carcinogen. We found no source showing that a particular Vaseline jar fails that test.
Unilever, since 1986. Aquaphor is owned by Beiersdorf.
A balm made with plant oils and beeswax. See the three petroleum-free picks above; the Earth Mama butter is also lanolin-free.
Evidence